In The Tank Comments

Reference Text

Comments Go Back
Today's date: Friday, July 30, 2010
Mike Barnett Monday, November 12, 2007
Mobile, Alabama, USA
Interesting comment about putting drugs and nasty stuff in candy. In the book "Made to Stick", this old wives tale was thoroughly analyzed. The research found that only 2 such incidents have ever been recorded on Halloween. One was a father-son child abuse case and the other a child got into his uncle's heroin and the uncle blamed it on someone tampering with the candy. The bottom line is no such incidents have ever occurred going back to 1959. Think of how this changed how we feel about strangers. I can remember hospitals offering to xray candy for free. Thanks for messages every day, they have done so much for so many. God bless.

SoundChaser Monday, November 05, 2007
"...someone convinced a group of already frightened Christians that they should really be sacred on Halloween..."

It's interesting that you used the words "frightened" and "sacred" in the same sentence. Flip two letters in "sacred" and you've got "scared," and that's how some people (such as the one you mention in that phrase) use "sacred." "BE SCARED - er, I mean sacred - AND OBEY!"

The word "sacred" (which is translated as "holy" in the KJV) simply means "consecrated, dedicated, set aside," and if one uses Halloween (or any other holiday) as you advise, well then, it's sacred! :-)

I haven't been a huge Halloween fan since my kids were little, but I'm not against it either. Paul tells us not to get our drawers in a wad over differences in "holy days," and I agree with him. EVERYTHING in our lives should be "sacred" - set aside and dedicated to our Lord - and Halloween should be no exception.

John, I'm with you 100% on this! Use EVERY opportunity to spread the Gospel, even Halloween! :-)

John Fischer Responds
Actually, I meant "scared." It was a Freudian typo.

annette pellegrino Sunday, November 04, 2007
valley stream, ny, usa
Hi, I just wanted to tell you that the origins of Halloween weren't in All Saints Day. In the 8th century the pope in an attempt to get the people to abandon the Festival of Samhain (Festival of Death, on Oct. 31st), established All Saint Day, to honor the Christian dead especially the martyrs of the Roman persicutions.He had hoped that having this holiday would cause the people to abandon the Festival of death but it wound up causing confusion as to the roots of the holidays. The fesival of death (Festival of Samhain) has been going on since approx. 500 years before the birth of Jesus! Now, I do disagree with you as far as being participants in this holiday, but I have no fear of this day, I don't shut myself in and pull down the shades and quiver in fear as you had suggested, but I don't participate, I set my family apart, and my 11 year old son, hasn't felt deprived, we feel that there are many holidays that as Christians we don't partipate in because they arent' "Our" holidays, Halloween is treated as the same. As a matter of fact, as Christians if we are going to participate in this pagan holiday, then why don't we participate in the Jewish holidays, it would seem to me that what we SHOULD participate in, like the passover, we don't and we are told to embrace a pagan day that in all aspects "appears to be evil". Sir, I don't agree! Thanks for allowing comments! Annette Pellegrino

LORI Sunday, November 04, 2007
Wetumpka, Alabama, USA
I don't completely agree with you about the trick or treating. I think going out to meet your neighbors is great, but I don't agree with the scary part. Being scary is what brings fear to children. When I was little I dressed up and went house to house, also. The problem was I wanted to be a witch! I was a witch every year! That is what lead to my obsesion of witchcraft as a teen. Even now at 33, I am drawn to shows that have witchcraft. Of course now, I don't watch them, but the temptation is always there. Parents need to really be careful with Halloween because it could lead to spiritual destruction. Thankfully, I had a praying grandmother that prayed me to the foot of the cross, but others may not be so lucky!

Mary Kay Hunt Saturday, November 03, 2007
Nashville, TN, USA
Thank you . So nice to hear and certainly an addition to help us enjoy life on the earth that the Lord has made for this time. We can certainly enjoy and glorify Him in all that He has given us.

joan fong Thursday, November 01, 2007
burnaby, BC, canada
As a children pastor, I have been racking my brain for years to come up with interesting “alternatives” for our children. We wanted them to stay off the streets and pagan practices. Finally it dawned on me (duh!), that not only I am sheltering the children, I am also encouraging this “entertain-me” attitude. I have seen kids going to different churches for their alternatives, because their prizes are better or their programs are more fun !!
I did the unthinkable one year, and cancelled our annual Halloween alternative, and encouraged the children to go “tract-and-treat” in their neighborhood. Instead of asking for treats, they will go and give out goody bags , it contains a gospel tract and some candies. The first time we did it , a lot of the neighbors were really surprised! The kids still get to dressed up and have fun while they bring the “Light of Christ” to their community. They learn to be missional and have fun at the same time. We have to stop catering to our children and encourage them to go out to the world of darkness to shine for Jesus.

Jolene Erickson Thursday, November 01, 2007
Davenport, WA, USA
Bravo John! I could not agree more completely. This is the first time I've taken the time to comment, but I find that so many times for me you absolutely hit the nail on the head. My coworker and I both subscribe to your devotional, and we end up discussing it almost daily. We are public health nurses in Washington state.

On a more personal note, I have forwarded your "catch" several times to my sister in an effort to reach out to her. She has not wanted a relationship with me for 8 years now. It's been tough, especially for our parents. She is estranged from my mom as well. It's difficult to understand how we cannot get along together as a family when all of us are practicing/professing Christians. For anyone else out there experiencing family discord, I ask for and will continue to lift up my own prayers for healing.

John Fischer Responds
...and we will for you.

Franc Woods Thursday, November 01, 2007
Roseville, CA, US
Excellent perspective! In fact, I seem to remember a similar take from your PDL tenure. I'd love to get a copy of that one (or a link to the archive). If memory serves me right, it was more into "not letting Satan win the day".

Thanks & God Bless
Franc

John Fischer Responds
Go to www.purposedrivenlife.com and research devotional archives.

Sandra Coyer Thursday, November 01, 2007
Bay City, Mi., USA
Hi John,
I have to be honest with you on this one, I do struggle where I stand. I believe we should encourage our children's imaginationa and creativity and give them a better choice on Halloween. I met the best Christian friend I have ever known at a Halloween party that was sponsored by a parent from our church. We did tradional things and had a great time. I remember the Youth for Christ really scarey barns on someone's farm. We had a wonderful time.

Now my best friend has a friend that has been taken by her step father as a child to Satan worship gatherings. (Her mother was ill, the step father would medicate her to knock her out then take the child.) She has such an awful time during the months of October and April. Special times for Satan worshipers. We want to honor this friend during these hard times and not add to her pain by having things around that trigger memories. Her experiences are real and more horrific than the mind can even wants to process. I pray for her and she has had much good Chrisitan counseling.

I pray God will give me the sensitivity in my dealings with her and yet her experiences are not mine.

Got any thoughts on this?

Thanks,

John Fischer Responds
I think you are right in being sensitive to her and should act accordingly.

Stanley Jones Thursday, November 01, 2007
Pensacola, Florida, USA
Hey John,
Enjoyed this article on Halloween. As a baptist preacher in a small community church all we did last night was have our prayer services as usual. We did however have a big bowl of candy at the door and one of our men greeted trick or treaters with candy a tract and a church flier. There were numerous kids and their parents who came to the door. We received many thank yous and God bless yous, as well as parents and children seeing the inside of their neighborhood church for the first time in their life. What man uses for evil God can turn it around and use it for Good. Happy belated Halloween Folks!
In His Service Bro. Stan

Kimberly Shaw Thursday, November 01, 2007
OH
Sorry, but I have to disagree with you on this one. I think maybe you have been deceived; and you are trying to justify it in your own mind that Halloween's ok to celebrate. We are not "scared" of Halloween; we just choose not to celebrate the day of the dead.

Carlos Rojas H. Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Cabimas, ZU, Venezuela
Greetings!

Your take on Halloween was certainly unexpected and interesting, and the story about the kid who dressed up as Satan is hilarious! In my country Halloween is felt as some strange commercial and foreign celebration with no purpose whatsoever. It simply isn't part of our culture, yet it is trumpeted in the media and in stores's windows. Needless to say, whatever is good and joyful about Halloween is not present here. I've never seen a kid treat-or-tricking and virtually no one expects kids to do it. So, what do Christians here know about Halloween? Apart from all that loud advertising, only what has been published in the once very popular J. T. Chick tracts and repeated endlessly in churches. Halloween = Satanic holiday.

I guess we are still a long way from realizing that nothing at all (NOTHING, no particular date, no music, no sound, no words) belongs to Satan. Whatever tools he uses to destroy come from a stolen loot that will all one day be restored to its rightful owner. Everything will be placed under Jesus' feet, and there everything will find meaning and contenment.

Which reminds me, when Jadis meets Aslan at the lion's encampment, she arrives proclaiming to be Queen of Narnia. Mr. Beaver is disgusted at her shamelessness and Aslan tells him something like "Be at peace, beaver. Soon every title will be restored to their rightful owners".

Blessings!

John Fischer Responds
I like your perspective!

Liz Lehman Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Murrieta, CA, Riverside
I was introduced to your daily comments/devotional, etc. by one of my daughters who lives in Azusa, Ca and is a Chair and a Professor, etc. at Asuza Pacific University ... was a softball coach for quite a few years ... any way my husband was a Pastor and he graduated to his enternal home in May of 2005. I look forward to opening my email every day and read your very special - funny - thought provoking - etc, comments.

I especially was cheering today when I saw your comment about Holoween ... I was a Christian Ed Direcotor for children's ministries for 5 years and some of the people decided that we should not do Halloween the "tradition way", but have a potluck dinner and have a movie ... not handing out candy or doing anything that would look like we were condoning Satan and his ways. Well, I told them they could plan and do everything - because I was going trick and treating with my grandchildren.

This morning I went to a coffee shop owened by some Christians and I asked the waitress why she wans't dressed up for Halloween and she gave me the "look" ... and the proceeded to give me a 2 minute sermon on why I was going down the wrong path. I told her that I was sick of people giving tribute to Satan and the I thought this holdiay was just a fun day from the time I was a little girl through all my years of being a mom ... and not a 72 year old grandma. She walked away from me and was polite through the rest of my breakfast - bringing me coffee, etc. So thanks for your ariticle today ... I looke forward every day to your new devotional. Thanks ... Liz Lehman ... from Murrieta, CA

John Fischer Responds
I trust you enjoyed your grandchildren and that they enjoyed you! I hope one of our other readers is catching this because she thought she was too old to trick-or-treat with her grandkids.

jim connelly Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Avalon, N.J., US
Thank you John. Halloween, Christmas are as blessed and as Christian as I want them to be and as I make them. God is near to me every breathing minute of everyday. So is Satan. I always have a choice. God sees into my heart and knows that I choose Him even when I don't because I am human and my heart and soul's desire is the love of God. Blessings, jim connelly

John Fischer Responds
I will take you to task on this one. Satan is not able to be near to you every breathing minute of everyday. Satan is only a fallen angel. He is not omni-present (can be everywhere at one time) like God. He has to rely on his demons (angels he brought with him in his rebellion against God) for information. Satan is not the opposite of God (eveything God is, Satan is the opposite). Don't give him that much credit.

Aristotle Damaskos Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Toledo, OH
Tonight it was polite night not fright night. the manners these kids displayed was amazing. Not many devils and ghosts either. Keep up the good work.
Rev. Aristotle Damaskos

John Fischer Responds
Our street was very well-behaved. Lots of princesses pirates and Star Wars characters. Three little guys came as the Three Amigos (they were very impressed that I got it right) and demanded three pieces each since there were three of them. You have to reward that kind of ingenuity!

Maribeth Gibson Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Jackson, MS, USA
Thank you, Thank you, Thank you! I have been trying for years to explain to people in my hometown that Halloween is not bad in and of it self and that it actually was started by the church and follows with tomorrows celebration of All Saints Day to celebrate and memorialize the dead who were faithful Christians. One church we attended the priest even was interviewed by the news trying to explain it too. I love the holiday and how our neighbors all come together since we are all so busy most of the time.

Thanks again and keep up the good work. I love reading your devotions. I would love to support you financially but we are having some tough times right now but I know it will get better soon.

Yours truly,

Maribeth Gibson

John Fischer Responds
Bless you. Thanks. Have a blessed All Saints Day.

Bonnie Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Powers, MI, USA
Dear John,

I hope you don't mind me posting again on this, but after reading the many posts, I wanted to share something I found helpful when I struggled regarding other traditions/holidays a couple of years ago.

After sharing my feelings with our pastor, he lead me to Romans 14. Perhaps the following verses would apply here...

Verse 5.) "One man esteemeth one day above another, another esteemeth every day alike. Let every man be fully persuaded in his own mind.
6.) He that regardeth the day, regardeth it unto the Lord; and he that regardeth not the day, to the Lord he doth not regard it....
12.) every one of us shall give account of himself to God.
13.) Let us not therefore judge one another any more, but judge this rather, that no man put a stumblingblock or an occasion to fall in his brothers way.

19.) Let us therefore follow after the things which make for peace, and things wherewith one may edify another.

Grace, peace and mercy to all,
Bonnie


John Fischer Responds
Yes. A perfect word for this discussion.

Joan Keith Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Lebanon, Pa, USA
Dear John (that sounds funny...like a 'Dear John' letter!):
ANYWAY, I want to thank you TREMENDOUSLY for today's (Halloween)
article! I have 'always' been unsure 'exactly' where Halloween
came from, and now I feel just 'great' about the fact that I 'no
longer' need to be a 'stuffy' Christian about it!!
Thanks again and thanks for ALL that you do that makes me (and I'm
SURE 'many' others) feel that they don't have to be 'perfect' to be a Christian!!....
Sincerely,

Joan Keith

Joshua Jackson Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Here we have yet another attempt to mask the truth with Christianity. So many christians want to feel like these holidays are harmless and sometimes "good." The truth is, Halloween originated in Ireland with the druids celebrating the end of summer by burning/sacrificing plants and animals.
Spreading lies is against what the bible teaches and as a Christ follower I know He was all about exposing the truth NOT adding to or continuing the lies.

John Fischer Responds
"He who seeks good, finds goodwill, but evil comes to him who searches for it." Proverbs 11:27 The origins of Halloween are in much debate and don't really factor into what it is today. I believe Halloween falls under the category of ambivalent cultural event and as the verse above suggests, you find what you are looking for.

Beth Wednesday, October 31, 2007
I couldn't agree with you more! It's such a fun night.....now, I'll go get on my witch costume and wait for the little guys with Giant Snickers bars in hand............;>)

Theresa Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Bakersfield, Ca., USA
Dear John,
I agree with you on celebrating Halloween. I love to stay home and joyfully give out candy to all the trick or treaters. My children are older (and still dress up to hand out candy with their friends, by the way) so my unsuspecting toy fox terrier gets dressed up every year to great the kids at the door! The kids and their parents love it. Sadie, not so much, she freezes until the door opens then she goes outside to greet the kids. They all giggle with delight. They come back each year to see what Sadie will dress up as, and to show us their wonderful costumes. My husband and I both remember trick or treating for hours, coming home with a pillow case full of candy that kept us on a sugar rush well into the next year! When our children were little we did both, "Trick or treating" and the churches "Harvest" celebtation. I have a neighbor who posts signs against Trick or Treating and family members who will take no part in it with their children too. I have never thought about it as an "evil" holiday, but a great night to share fun and fellowship with those in our community. Have a wonderful evening doing the same with Chandler and your community tonight!

Toni Petrella Wednesday, October 31, 2007
North Las Vegas , Nevada, USA
Dear Mr Fischer

I have always seen today as a fun time with parents and children. Greg and I give out candy every year and I would not have it any other way. I remember a boss of mine in the military who saw it as a day of Satan. He was something else seeing this day like that and not to be celebrated and then after he retired from the military he was indicted on nineteen counts of child molestation in Fairfield California back in the fall of 1990 so go figure.

Sincerely

Toni Petrella

John Fischer Responds
Yikes!

Kristen Rose Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Sault Ste. Marie, ON, Canada
Thank you so much John! I really needed to hear that. I've been struggling with this issue over the past several weeks. I'm a mother of an almost 2 year old and have been a Christian about as long. Many families at our Church have nothing to do with Halloween, but I really didn't know what I thought of it from a Christian perspective. I didn't see any harm in putting up some decorations and taking my son out for all to see him in his tiger costume, but I almost felt bad knowing that many think doing so is evil. After reading your message today I found out where Halloween initially came from and realized that it's ok to celebrate this day. The Catch really eased my mind. Thanks

Barb Hedgepeth Wednesday, October 31, 2007
detroit, mi, usa
Thanks John! I thought it was me. My two children Carson and Connor are 8 and 4 respectively and we are devout Christians who celebrate the fun Holiday every year. I take my children to church and teach them about how to live God fearing lives. But since Carson's 1st Halloween, some belivers have made me question if what I was doing was somehow Sacrilegious. Your message helped to remind me not to give anything over to the enemy. By the way, my boys will both be Darth Vader this year, red lightsabers and all.

Jackie Steeby Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Caledonia, Michigan, USA
Thank you so much John -- finally a voice of reason. Hope Chandler, and you, have a fantastic time. Jackie

Jeanne Kelly Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Madison, MS, USA
Thank you so much for writing this. I'm 62, and my daddy was a Baptist preacher. We always celebrated Halloween--though we got by with homemade costumes. The neighbors pretended to be frightened and acted as if they didn't know who the masks covered up.

If one believes something is Satanic, then I suppose that makes it so for him or her. As for the rest of us, we say let the kids have some fond memories of tromping through neighborhood in groups and collecting enough sugar to run their parents completely crazy for a few days. (That's the fun of being a kid.)


John Fischer Responds
I like it.

Greg Pickering Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Lake Jackson, TX, USA
Yes! Yes! Yes!
John, I'm a pastor of a relatively new church whose mission is to reach people who wouldn't consider going to a traditional church to find answers to life's questions. The fear and withdrawal response many Christians have embraced for Halloween has hurt the cause of Christ. So this past Sunday I spoke about it and challenged folks to enbrace the opportunity and potential of Halloween, much like your thoughts today. I even interviewed a former Halloween Scrooge (our Children's Minister) during the message. Tonight she and many others in our church will be passing out candy and smiles for the first time in years.

John Fischer Responds
This made me smile.

Stacey George Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Rio Linda, CA, USA
Yes, you have time. I'm just getting to know more deeply, my 28 yr old son. He was raised in a different state and knew me only from occasional visits. He now is getting to know the real me. And he's sad for what he missed. He's estatic for what he has gained. Show them what they missed and how much more they have to gain. Trust me, they will love you all the more. And you will be amazed at the depth of love God will show you.

Mary Ann Wednesday, October 31, 2007
MI
John,

You are so right about Holloween! I remember how exciting and fun it was to dress up in a costume and go door to door and get candy.
I saved my old costumes and would go trick or treating 3 different times in my neighborhood with 3 different costumes. I got three times as much candy that way. That was my "TRICK" (I was a clever little kid!!)

Mary Ann

John Fischer Responds
I bet you're still pretty clever, too.

lorraine Wednesday, October 31, 2007
ada, mi, usa
We walk by faith and not by sight. Just because we can not
see the evil around us, does not make it not there. Because
God gives us light that maybe we didn't have years ago, gives
us something to pray about and not fear by any means. Many
things we didn't know years ago, and that doesn't make them
any less valid so we just need to keep walking in faith.
blessings,lorraine

John Fischer Responds
Yes, but remember, "He who seek good finds good will, but evil comes to him who searches for it." (Proverbs 11:27)

John OConnor Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Scottsdale, AZ, USA
My son is about to turn 7-years old and he is going as Darth Vader. I was never really into the Star Wars stuff until my son began watching the movies, some 5-times.

Never-the-less, I have never allowed my Christian companions to ruin the activities of Halloween, no matter how much fright they choose to stir-up about the satanic references and foolish beliefs. As John F. has mentioned, it was an evening that honored those persecuted for their faith, and evolved into many nuances of that theme, until our present tradition of 'tricks & treats'. It is as innocent or evil as YOU choose to make. For me, having the children dressed in costumes, visiting our door with an excitement only matched by birthdays & Christmas seems refreshing and wholesome. They're so innocent themselves that to derive some impurity from their costumes to the tradition; seems to imply a witch-hunt of fanatical proportion (pun-intended).

Sheri Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Seal Beach, CA, USA
Thank you for that! My husband says when he was a kid they even made a haunted house out of their church. Yowza...how times have changed.

I think it's important to realize that this is the one day in the year when everyone in the neighborhood is coming to your door. As Christians we should see what an incredible opportunity this is. My friend makes chili and puts chairs out and invites anyone in the neighborhood to come and hang out. Now her neighbors expect it. FABULOUS!!!

John Fischer Responds
Yes. Youth for Christ used to do elaborate haunted houses to scare kids into the kingdom.

Cheryl Hyter Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Bravo John!

I did not grow up as a Christian, nor did my kids. I've been saved about 12 years, but the memory of the "Christians" in the neighborhood who darkened their houses and turned their backs on the kids' fun night is something that none of us will ever forget. We are in the world, but not of the world. If we make the most of every opportunity and don't slam the door on people, I think it is a much better witness on how to love people. I don't think that Satan was affected by those neighbors who left the house dark, but I know that me and my kids were.

While I've lost my passion for decorating to the 10's, I always want to give the kids who make it to my house a candy reward to remember, and show them love and kindness.

Happy Halloween!
Cheryl <><

John Fischer Responds
Hear this person. This is important.

Linda Sherblom Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Oakley, Id, USA
Hurray for you, John! You are so human- that's what I love about you. I get so tired of the "demons in the doorknobs" mentality. The fun has been taken out of everything for our kids these days. They are taught to be afraid of evrything. You can't even ride a bike any more without a ton of "Protective equipment." How did we ever survive this long? Isn't God big enough to protect us from what we need to be protected from? Keep up the good work-as soon as I am able, I plan on being a Fischtank supporter!

Debbie G. Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Valley Springs, CA, USA
You know, I was really glad to read your devotional today. Understandably, we as Christians sometimes miss the point in our efforts to remain "set apart" in this world and lose out on countless opportunities - even with something as trivial as a little Halloween fun. Unfortunately, what usually happens is we end up being viewed as disagreeable people. I admit, I think I was starting to become a "disagreeable" person until I began a study my church is doing called OUTFLOW by Steve Sjogren and Dave Ping - a most enlightening little book on how God's love can overflow through us and into our family & friends, community and our world. Let's just say somebody turned the light upstairs and I'm now seeing things through different eyes (and heart)!

Okay, so I appreciate your words today and am happy to hear that Chandler is dressing up as a storm trooper (may the "force" be with him), but what about you, John? What are you going as?

John Fischer Responds
Dad.

Jovonn Rochester Wednesday, October 31, 2007
College Point, New York, United States
John, I have been reading your Catch of the Day for quite a few months now but never sent in a comment. This one absolutely made my day and I just had to let you know! As a little girl I used to go trick or treating every year and so enjoyed it! Back in the late 60's and early 70's before all the craziness really got started we even used to go to some houses where they offered baked goods like cookies, or cupcakes along with cartons of milk or juice! You were even able to go into some peoples homes where in their front hallway you could grab a handful of candy or some other delightful treat! Now, sadly we have to tell our children not to eat anything before coming home and never ever to go into someones home even if you "know them"
But once I became a Christian back in 1989 and started going to a pentacostal Church I was made to feel "guilty" for allowing my children to participate in this "evil holiday" You can only imagine how my children felt back then when suddenly I took this holiday celebration away from them! Since then I came to the conclusion that I know I love the Lord and that I wasn't going to let anyone, Church, Pastor etc... tell me how to run my home and make me feel bad for allowing my children to go trick or treating or now since they're older, still participate by decorating and giving out lots and lots of candy to the little monsters and goblins that ring my doorbell!! I like you even get into to the spirit of the holiday so much so that I put on Michael Jackson's thriller or a CD of haunted sounds and even dress up myself!! LOL

So I just want to say a great big THANK YOU!!! For letting me for the first time in years, enjoy this holiday without any feelings of guilt!

God bless you and your ministry,

Myrna Thiessen Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Morden, MB, Canada
Hi John,

Oh I so agree with you about Halloween!!! I went trick or treating as a kid and lived in a Christian home and never heard about it being satan's holiday back then. It's such a huge controversial thing among Christian's it seems. Every year the subject comes up and every year there are Christian's who are totally against it and Christian's who are not.

I took my kids trick or treating when they were young and loved it! I still enjoy Halloween for handing out candy and look forward to taking my grandchildren out some day.

Tonight I'm going to our Church alternative to help out with games. My husband is staying home to hand out candy. In fact, we have to go buy more candy because my husband couldn't leave the candies alone that I did buy for tonight. LOL! He looks forward to handing out candy every year. :)

I liked your idea of hiding in the bushes and scaring the kids, having some fun with them too.

Be Blessed, John & Family!!!

Sincerely,
Myrna

Wayne Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Little Rock, AR, 72209
Thanks for your insight bro..

Can't and won't argue with it. Isn't it wonderful that Christ has made set us free and allows us to choose. For those that choose to celebrate....GOOD FOR YA!! For those that choose to abstain from the festivities...GOOD FOR YA!!! Honestly, I think in this day and time that both "camps" can tend to chide the other for the way in which they view the whole thing. Today I read back thru Paul's writings to the Corinthians in Chapter 8 about "Freedom with Responsibility-Message). He concludes by encouraging them to be mindful of how our choices can impact and/or influence other Christians around us. So, if you and your family choose to participate, do so with a good heart, if you choose to refrain, do so with a good heart... however, be considerate not to wag our heads (or fingers) at a brother or sister who chooses the opposite. Just a thought.

John Fischer Responds
Very good point. I think there are similarities in the issues, too, but we need to be careful not to offend. The one thing that I will have a long talk with Paul about when I get to heaven is the issue of the "weaker brother" being the one who thinks eating meat offered to idols is a sin. My problem, if we keep catering to his belief (which Paul admits is not true since there is no such thing as an idol), how is he ever going to grow up? Are we not endorsing his incorrect thinking? It seems to me also that if I have to respect my weaker brother's legalism, I'm not helping him either. I'm not sure we always interpret this passage correctly.

My point in speaking about this is to show arguments on the side of freedom so that people may grow thereby. How long are we supposed to stay weak?

Vondel Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Thanks for your "Catch" today. It was great to hear your balanced approach to Halloween, and I really enjoyed the comments from readers.
I just had to respond to the grandmother who thought her 14 year old grandson was too old to trick-or-treat. I'm not certain what "too old" is. I went trick-or-treating when I was still in college. It was great fun to create a costume out of things you could get cheaply or already had. (I was the Bunch of Grapes from the Fruit of the Loom Guys one year. My costume was a bunch of purple balloons tied together to look like grapes and a green beret on my head. [Yeah, I'm a looney tune ;-) ]
A couple of years ago, my best friend and I bought candy, dressed up as Little Red Riding Hood and The Wolf, and went "reverse trick or treating". We went to the 3 retirement/assisted living communities in our town and passed out candy to the residents. We had a blast and the residents loved it. (I should tell you that we were in our late 40's, so it is debatable as to how old is too old!)
The main thing is that we as Christians should be the most joyful and be having more fun than anyone because God is good and He has given us His message of love and grace! I never want to outgrow the joy and fun.
Thanks again for the great "Catch"

John Fischer Responds
Every year we have some parents come to the door all dressed up too.

Traci Rodriguez Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Modesto, CA, USA
Finally - another Christian who understands the holiday and is not afraid of it. Our church also does the whole ' We will not glorify satan!' theme. My husband & I just go ahead & dress our kids up(this year one is a slice of half eaten pizza and the other is a football), go pumpkin hunting and trick or treating. It's nice to know that there are other non-paranoid Christians out there!

God Bless!

Jeannette Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Lompoc, CA
Great devotional once more! I was also raised in a mainline denominational church - and my Dad was the pastor! We did the trick or treat thing. I think we are certainly products of our generation AND our environment when it comes to this subject. I grew up in the Midwest, small town and we were not allowed to do things like dances, movies, wear earrings,even bowling! However, if I never remember one other thing that my parents taught me it was that God looks on the heart and not on the outward appearance of things. I think this includes trick or treating with the FUN intended. I can't wait to see my grandkids costumes!

ken anderson Wednesday, October 31, 2007
clinton, me. , USA
Thank you for setting the record straight. What a novel idea of using Halloween to enlarge the Kingdom of God. This will be sent to everyone on my list and any others i can get it to. i praise God for your ministry. ken

Charlie Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Riverside, CA, Riverside
Thanks, John, for today's Catch. I like your perspective. It's a good reminder that I might miss connecting with some people if I choose not to participate in some way. The candy will be ready...

Keep writing!


Lori Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Poughkeepsie
This year I have been pleased that three different religious sources I subscribe to have said it's ok to participate in Halloween festivities. I have always participated in spite of people who claim it's pagan and evil except for last year when my porch was broken and it wasn't safe for trick or treaters. One devotional suggested giving out Bible verses or tracts along with the candy. Therefore last night my 8 year old and I enjoyed stuffing bags with candy and slips with the verse John 3:16 printed on them. My son who attends a Christian school thought this was a great idea and even insisted on helping type the verse.

John Fischer Responds
This is okay, I suppose, but personal relationships are stronger.

Douglas Drake Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Castro Valley, California
John,

Been meaning to write for a time now...been following your devotions from the 40 Days of Purpose time. My family goes back with you to Peninsula Bible Church...Pastor Steadman, Ron Ritchie, sunday night body life, etc. My younger brother actually has been a pastor at PBC South for ten+ years now. Back in high school I hung out with Ron Ritchie's son - we even came over to your house once in Half moon Bay...I think we were supposed to be babysitting, but we had too much fun. I am not writing this in hopes of stirring any memories...but in that your article today brought a smile to my face. It's not the profound, deep thoughts that you write, but the personal "hey, I can relate to that" true life moments that usually brings a smile to my face. Your line about Chandler and his storm trooper outfit did that for me today. See, I have a ten year old son, Noah, and for the last three years, a character from Star Wars is the only thing that he was willing to dress up as. He has been Luke Skywalker, the young Anakin, and has now succumbed to the draw of Darth Vader - the cape, the light saber, the mask. The irony of this is that when I was in the high school group at PBC...we had a Halloween night at someone's house, put on by the high school staff and they gave out prizes for the best costumes. The first time I went, I spent days creating a Darth Vader costume for me. I made the mask out of paper mache' (before they even thought to make costumes of the characters) I made the belt with working lights using batteries inside little cardboard boxes. I went to the party and didn't speak a word, just breathed heavily...hahaha...so when I won the best costume prize no one knew who it was. I say all this, realizing and knowing that my son is just like me...I get him. Your son is just like you. It brings a smile to my face even now, because our heavenly Father wants us to be just like His Son. The greatest compliment I could receive is that my son wants to be like me.

John Fischer Responds
Thanks. This is great. Brought a smile to my face, too.

Kim Waters Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Pensacola, Florida, USA
A friend of mine gave me a card that reads like this: How is being a Christian like being a pumpkin? God sees us, picks us out of the dirt, cleans us off, takes the yucky material out of us by forgiving us, puts a smile on our faces and places a shining light within us for others to see. Jesus said: "Let your light shine before others, so that they may see your good works and give glory to your Father in heaven." (Matthew 5:16, NRSV)

I think it would be kinda hard to "let your light shine" if you turned off all your house lights and hid in the dark while others were "seeking" you out!!!

You Go - Fischtank Man!!!

Noelle Massey Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Sachse, TX, USA
Amen, Amen, Amen! What a wonderful thing to hear! I have thought that Halloween was a good way to meet and catch up with neighbors for years! I am so glad that you were bold enough to speak up!
Thank you!
My kids have heard over the years the way God works in us through our pumpkin carving. We remove the yucky, sticky, nasty seeds and pulp from the inside like God removes sin from our lives. God puts a smile in our heart and on our faces (only happy pumpkins at my house)and His light shines through us for all the world to see!
They love it!

Becky Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Uxbridge, MA
Hi John- Let me start off by saying, I completely agree with your message today! Thank you! BUT I forwarded this to my husband who has been a Christian far longer than me, and he wasn't impressed!! I disagree with him but find it interesting the different ideas everyone has on the topic. My husband forwarded me this little tidbit :)(and I apologize, I am not sure who the author of this is).

"Whether we feel that we have been really hurt by celebrating Halloween or not, is only part of the issue. How does God feel to see His people making light of demons and witchcraft? Shouldn't we be thinking about how to honor Him and show our love to Him? Where do our loyalties lie?
Most Satanists celebrate this as their high holy day and even offer human sacrifices to the devil. Until recently, most Christians have not questioned this traditional celebration, but rather have gone along with it by even bringing Halloween parties into the church. The earliest Halloween celebrations were not held by the early church, but the Druids in honor of Samhain, the "lord of the dead", and his demons, whose festival fell on November 1. Halloween actually means "holy or hallowed evening."
According to the Roman calendar in which days began at midnight, the evening of October 31 was the eve before the hallowed day; hence Halloween or All Soul's Eve was kept throughout the ancient pagan world. All Hallows Eve, because it is the day before All Hallows' or All Saints' day, was a holy day in the Roman Catholic Church, Episcopal Church, the Church of England and the Greek Orthodox Church. This festival honors all martyrs, known and unknown, who have died for the church. During the time of Constantine, these two holidays were merged in an attempt to Christianize the heathen. The church could not prevent these heathen practices, so they thought "taming'" them would be the answer. They were, of course, not to worship their gods on the church's "All Saint's day." However, as it is with all compromises, soon the evil overrode the good, and hence we still honor these heathen practices by celebrating Halloween.
Parents have a responsibility not to allow their children to be exposed to these evil celebrations. What might seem to some as innocent children's games is a "little fox" that can open the door to satanic influence and even demon possession in some cases. Children can be tormented with a spirit of fear that can come through this involvement that stays with them throughout their lives. It also introduces children to witchcraft, making it easier for them to become involved in cults and occultic activities. When children are taught it is alright to play with the things of darkness, it does not give them the repulsion and resistance that they need to stand against greater Satanic involvement. When the things of Satan are taken lightly, as games and fun, it sets our children up to accept evil rather than to resist it. This "little fox" is not only spreading evil to children but has been a curse for the church and our nation as well. As Christians, we should spread the word to others about the evil tradition of Halloween."

John Fischer Responds
To make fun of things is not to deny their existence. We make fun of each other in our families so as not to take ourselves so seriously. We can talk to our children about the real Satan and his demons that are out there and assure them that Halloween is play and not real. I also have noticed that a very small percentage of kids represent these evil personifications. Most, if not all, are playing dress-up. Some are incredibly creative.

Linda Kay Murray Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Kenova, WV, USA
Thank you John--need I say more about your October 31st article on Halloween.
I bet Chandler looked adorable. My daughter Allie, age 7, was Marilyn Monroe!
Thank you for all your inspiration. You're great.

Krista Clements Orlan Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Thank you! Halloween is my favorite holiday because of all the positive things you mentioned. Christmas, Easter, and Thanksgiving all tend to be "stay at home with the family" sort of holidays and this is one of the few that is all about celebrating with the strangers in your community.

Isn't it amazing how we've become afraid of the holiday where we're supposed to face our fears? We make fun of the monsters under our beds, decorate the house with spiders that normally send us into fits, and walk up to the doorstep of the neighbor we haven't said two words to all year. Death is all around and we are celebrating it. Tomorrow is All Saints Day, the day we celebrate all of those "spiritual giants" who made it to heaven and all of us who remain here with our faith in Christ's salvation.

This year it seems a lot of people are afraid of Halloween in our town. One church is having an Hallelujah Night, another is having a Kingdom Night, and another is offering "Trunk or Treating" in their parking lot. (I'm not understanding how encouraging kids to take candy from stranger's cars is any better than going up to their front door.) Apart from the trunk or treating, all of these celebrations will involve staying within comfort zones of environment, acquaintance, and content. Not much facing of fears going on here.

Thanks for talking about how we've allowed Satan to claim a Christian holiday. We're going to claim in back tonight by following tried and true tradition.

Kellie Wednesday, October 31, 2007
STOCKBRIDGE, GA, United States
And one more thing.

For those who don't want to celebrate Halloween, another alternative is to still greet the trick-or-treaters who come to your door. In addtion to giving them candy, also give them an invite to your church.

Especially if you have a strong youth or children's program, or are trying to build one, have your church plan something the weekend that follows Halloween and use a piece of candy and a small piece of paper with an invite on it to get them into your doors.

This is what we want isn't it... to tell the world about Christ? What an opportunity.

Cindy Weatherall Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Pensacola, FL, Escambia
Thanks for addressing Halloween!! I have worked in a church now for nearly 15 years & have never quite understood why everyone was pulling their children from celebrating Halloween. When my daughter (who is now 18) asked me if she could trick-or-treat, I always let her. I told her that I trick-or-treat-ed all of my life and I'm not Satanic. Somewhere down the line we Chrisitians did lose our perspective on this holiday! Since when can Christ not shine on Halloween?! Enjoy your night -- and thanks, John!

kellie Wednesday, October 31, 2007
stockBRIDGE
Amen, brotha!!!!!

You hit it right on the head. This should be fun and joyful and should be shared with our Christian and non-Christian neighbors.

dianne Wednesday, October 31, 2007
wa
i just read over the 20 comments previous to mine, john, and it looks as though my heart is in the minority. i am like the child who can't wait until halloween is over - i imagine satan must laugh at Christians who feel torn between taking part along with everyone around them and taking a stand and being ridiculed for it when they take that stand. i also appreciate the opportunity to reach out, if it is done authentically, to those at our door. some years we've gone to the "alternative" celebrations, we've simply gone out, and we've stayed home ... the past several years i've gathered small handouts that share the good new of Jesus through the trick-or-treat theme and handed those out along with the treat at the door. i pray as i prepare that the truth will be planted in even one heart through the Scripture there. for those with children could i recommend a book by Harold Myra (sp?) called "Halloween, is it for real?" he has also written excellent books for Christmas and for Easter that tell the truth about the traditions around these days while still affirming what is good and worth celebrating.

John Fischer Responds
If you use a handout, be sure and give candy too. Otherwise that becomes like leaving the "tip" that is a fake dollar bill with the gospel on the other side.

Sue Lynch Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Temple, TX
Hi, John,

It dawned on me before I started writing this that I should read the other comments first, and sure enough, there was a note about "scared" and "sacred." I was pretty sure it was supposed to be scared, but I LOVED the Freudian slip. This is a wonderful message, and I only wish more Christians would think this way, too.
Sue

Doyle Patrick Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Mobile, AL, USA
Thank you for your comment today. I get so tired of christians trying to out christian everyone. Who will fill the void if God's people run and hide?

John Fischer Responds
Yes. Non-participation on Halloween will make nothing but a negative impact on our neighborhood for Christ. Our reasons for staying away are known only to us. It's similar to the "testimony" I was supposed to have in grade school by not participating in school dances because it was "against my religion." No one, including me, ever got it.

cliff Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Princeton, KY, usa
I agree with everything you said! Our church is going to have a halloween party for our youth group tonight. They asked if they could dress up--I said, "Of course!"

One asked,"Do we have to be Bible characters"

I laughed and said, "Only if you want to be one."

Tonight can be one of the best tools to get to know your neighbors and opportunity to become friends than any I know as everyone is out and about. So I agree turn the lights on and celebrate kids!

Chad Mager Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Marquette, MI, USA
John,
After agreeing with 1,000 of your articles, blogs, books, etc over the years, I've not once commented about something that spoke to my heart or challenged me or that I excitedly shared with family and friends because it was so "right on". So the fact that my first comments will end up being lumped into the disagree category I find disturbingly ironic.
Anyway, my only problem with Halloween is: Fear.
I work with teenagers as my occupation and have been for several years now. I don't buy into the whole Satanic origins stuff (although I was raised that way and all of the "Autumn parties" and anti-Halloween stuff), or think we should hide from the culture on this night, but I do have a problem with the fear factor.
I challenge parents I know, NOT about trick-or-treating, NOT about attending a party (or better yet throwing one!), but rather on what they emphasize as the theme and purpose of the holiday.
As a parent of 3 young children (9,7,6), I work 364 days a year to help dispel or calm their fears (as I think most parents do), but because of some holiday that glorifies freaking people out I should just let my kids go get a good "scare"? I've never been comfortable with that and I came up with that conclusion before my youngest was even old enough to trick-or-treat. Not to get super-spiritual here (not my style), but I think one of the enemy's greatest weapons is using our fears, whatever they may be.
Another commenter mentioned something along these lines already and much more eloquently, so I won't keep repeating everything, but I challenged some of the teens I work with on this idea and believe it or not, some actually got my point. Most didn't care, of course, but a few saw my point (one even admitted to me that they hate the holiday because of all the fears they have and how "friends" exploit that during this season).
My work with the teens is extreme outreach. We do stuff all the time that makes the church cringe because they don't agree with our methods or how culturally relevant we're attempting to be, so this is not an issue of not wanting to engage our culture, cause we do it all the time. For me, personally, it's about not promoting fear.
And to all those enjoying the day without amping up the fear factor, I say, excellent work, because I believe you can still enjoy this fun holiday without glorifying the horror, the fear and the grotesque.
That's what me and my family will be doing.
So ultimately, I'm not disagreeing, I guess, because I'll be out there meeting new people tonight much like you. That's what we do when we're attempting to be salt and light (and heck, I really like some of my neighbors and folks in this community, so it's not hard to enjoy being around them and making new friends!)
But my final thoughts are to enjoy the holiday, don't close ourselves away, but don't give in to scaring the crap out of little kids. You're not the one who has to be up with them when they have nightmares or can't get images out of their heads for years. We parents get that job.

John Fischer Responds
Could it be that there is something even "comforting" in a "scare" that really isn't one? Like coming up behind someone and going: "Boo!" and finding out it was just a friendly scare. Might that not be something that in the long run can help dispel fear? In the end, we all come back to the warmth of our lighted home, take off our masks and are assured in the fact that after all, it's just us. Such experiences can strengthen our ability to tell the difference between fact and fantasy. The people who are afraid of everything are the people that really scare me.

Constance Reed Wednesday, October 31, 2007
I, too, was raised in a "fundamentalist, legalistic, God-fearing, Bible-quoting, practically-live-at-the-church household," and we, too, always celebrated Halloween. I don't know at what point I began to view Halloween as a pagan holiday - it was after my daughter was grown (so thankfully, she didn't have to miss out on all the fun), but when it was time for my grandson to participate, both my daughter and I (from teachings at church) decided that he should not be allowed to honor Satan - so we did the alternative stuff with him, and he never enjoyed the pleasure of trick-or-treating - until this year. Of course, by now, in my opinion, he's much too old to be trick-or-treating (turned 14 last Saturday), but he is so extremely excited. He's going as an American soldier, he has carved a pumpkin, decorated his house (he's very artistic and creative), and is really into it. I'm really uncomfortable that's he's not going to be accompanied by an adult, but just a friend his same age - I no longer live close to him, and he would be agast, I'm quite sure, at the prospect of his "Grammie" tagging along. So, I would ask that you please pray for him in his first xperience of trick-or-treating, in spite of the fact that he's too old to be doing so. Oh - and Happy Halloween!

John Fischer Responds
I'm not so sure he would be against Grammie coming along -- especially if you went as soomeone else and played along. Too bad you're not closer.

Sylvia Beamesderfer Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Lebanon, PA, USA
Good to know that there are lots of Star Wars fans out there. Our 8 month old grandson is going to be dressed as Yoda!!!!! He is about the same size!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Have a great time with your son.

Pam B. Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Richmond, TX, USA
John...

I am forwarding an email that I just sent out to our women's Bible study that I lead on Wednesday nights.

"Hmmm....a Christian's view of Halloween...interesting:-) And IF we were home tonight instead of being at church, our lights would be on to welcome our neighbors children as we have done in the past. Instead, I took some "goody" bags to my neighbor's houses and explained we wouldn't be home (and why) but still wanted to say hello and give a treat. Their responses were well worth the effort:-)

Pam<><"

Thanks for your perspective on a confusing day for some.

Thomas E Allen Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Horseheads, NY, USA
Superb treatment of a "touchy" subject, John. I appreciate the way that you turn everything into an opportunity for "Great Commandment, Great Commission" fulfillment. We want to be "that special house" in our neighborhood, too! Blessings!

Tom Allen

Aristotle Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Toledo, OH
John,
The best Halloween story I've read. Thanks for your message. Here is what I have been sharing:

The Re-Baptism of Halloween
There has been much controversy in the recent years regarding the celebration of Halloween. Yes, it is true the origins of Halloween are based on pagan rituals and, some believe, sacrifices of animals and humans.

However, if we look at where Halloween began and where it has ended up today we can see there is a big difference. Thus, I am exhorting Orthodox Christians to lead the way in transforming Halloween from a pagan holiday to a Christian Holiday.

This is not a novel concept, as it has been done in the past to many of the Christian Holidays we celebrate. Case in point is Christmas. The celebration of Christmas on December 25 was established in 274 A.D. in order to combat the pagan feast of the Un-conquered Sun, which is the winter solstice (December 21, the shortest day of the year).
In short, a celebration that the days were in fact getting longer.

It was sometime before 336 A.D. the church in Rome was unable to stamp out this pagan feast and spiritualize it as the Feast of the Nativity of the Sun Righteousness.

The celebration of Christmas on December 25th was ecognized by various patriarchs; Rome in 336 A.D., Antioch in 375 A.D, Constantinople in 380 A.D., and Alexandria in 430 A.D..

The various traditional customs associated with Christmas also have roots in the pagan holidays. The merry making and the exchanging of presents comes from the Roman pagan Saturnalia festival, which was celebrated December 17-24. Saturnalia was the feast of Saturn marked by wild reveling and licentious behavior.

I mention this bit of history to show that we have in fact transformed a pagan feast into a Christian celebration. Therefore, precedent is set where we can do the same for Halloween.

For example, tradition tells us that the lit carved pumpkins were used to frighten away the evil spirits. Why can’t we transform the lit pumpkin to remind us of Christ’s words, “I am the Light of the world, they who follow me will not walk in darkness, but have the
light of life.” John 8:12. Cannot the candle lit pumpkin remind us of Jesus Christ the Light of the world, Who is guiding our every step we take?

What are some other options that we can use in the transformation of Halloween?

I know an Orthodox teacher who uses Halloween to teach her students about the skeletal system, bats, the scarecrow, the harvest and about the vegetable, the pumpkin.

Also, there are several churches that encourage their children to dress up as their favorite biblical person or their favorite saint.

Our Church teaches balance and moderation. Thus, I believe we as Christian leaders must take the same approach with Halloween. Let us expel the Satanic aspects of the feast and attach ourselves with a Christian message.

Let’s face it, we have an appealing holiday at our doorstep which the majority of our children celebrate, why not, as a church, use it to gather our youth to have a celebration of Christ, the Light of the world who is the conqueror of sin and the devil. What a great evangelistic tool.

I personally feel the more attention we give to the occult aspect of Halloween, the more children with inquiring minds will investigate. Moreover, if you ask any child what Halloween is about, they will unequivocally respond, “candy, being with friends, and
having fun.”

It is amazing that with all the tricker treaters, who came to our house last Halloween, I did not see one witch, a devil or a ghost. What does this tell us? Halloween can be devil free but maybe not fat free!

Scripture reminds us that, “Where two or three are gathered, I am there.” Thus, we can transform Halloween as a celebration that Christ is victorious and is the conqueror of sin and the devil.



Marsha Brown Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Clifton, Texas, USA
I know you will be deluged with comments on this Halloween writing. I love it! I have grown children ages 26 & 28 and always let them do Halloween. Sometimes we did a church party, too, but we always "trick-or-treated". They have grown up to be responsible, God fearing/loving adults.
As a child growing up in a small Texas town, Halloween was just the greatest thing that ever happened! We actually lived in the country, but my parents and my aunt and uncle who had not children took us into town. It was almost like a town full of partying people doing as you described walking over town/ adults visiting. Great memories!!!!
marsha brown
clifton,texas

John Wednesday, October 31, 2007
John,

Thanks for sharing the truth about Hallowe'en. The difference between Scared and Sacred is getting the details confused (the letter order). The modern American church has been a little dyslexic about Hallowe'en for about 40 years.

Those of us old enough to know better, should recognize the opportunity to communicate with our neighbors about the evil of this age, while expressing the Goodness of God. We should also recognize the responsibility of not abandoning celebration of life.

If you go to a costume party, go as the Mummy of scripture - Lazarus. Celebrate the 'Frankenstein's monster' that is the "Body of Christ". And tell someone that knows the truth about All Hallows Evening - "Remember, we can pretend that the devil wins for one night, but we all know that God reigns for all eternity".

Merle Peters Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Winkler, MB, Canada
Thank-you Thank-you Thank-you. Our community is one of those "Christian" communities that is trying to scare people into the "alternative" celebrations. Now, for those that feel safe there, I'm cool with that, however, I agree with you in that it's not Satan's holiday unless we allow it to be.
As a kid I had a great time going house to house dressed up as something or other, never a thought about anything deeper than how much candy could I collect in one evening.
It was a fun evening with friends. It is too bad that there are people out there spoiling the fun by sabotaging the candy, but if you're careful as a parent, you can avoid any disasters.
Thanks again for your straight forwardness and tongue in cheek way of telling us it's ok to come out from under the bed tonight....

Marina Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Kennesaw, GA, USA
John - Thank you so much for today's message. I have friends who have tried to convince me that Halloween is evil and I just don't agree. How can my 7 year old, who is dressing up as a horse this year and who is only concerned about candy, be evil?? Let's join together and keep this day for Christ! Hope Chandler shares the good stuff with you. Have fun tonight!!

Emily Nighswander Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Kitchener , Ontario, Canada
Please read it again!!

A few years ago someone convinced a group of already frightened Christians that they should really be sacred (MMMMM DID YOU MEAN SCARED??) on Halloween, so that's when the bad news of Satan's holiday spread all over

Ha ha .. Be careful that SANTA doesn't become SATAN!!!

Love your meditations. Keep them a-coming.

John Fischer Responds
Oh my goodness... was that a Freudian typo?

Carolyn Langdon Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Four Oaks, NC, USA
John,

Enjoy your devotionals usually, but this one I must comment on.

I don't think you should characterize those who have chosen to go the route of an "alternative celebration" as quitters or as "allowing those who have highjacked the holiday (darkness lovers) to win!" If, indeed, the holiday celebrates former martyred believers than it seems to me this highjacking occurred a long, long time ago. It was our grandparents who were the weak ones, not us, when they remained silent, went along with the crowd and allowed this sacred holiday to go the darkened and commercial direction it has gone (as all sacred holidays have). They apathetically allowed it to be perverted into something unholy and one of the most self-centered activities of the year. "Trick or treat" has now come to mean, "Give me some of that candy or else you will seriously regret it!"

We who don't participate in it in the form in which it has developed over the years are simply trying to be pro-active rather than complacent. We are trying to take it back to the more proper and god-honoring celebration it deserves, rather than keeping it one which promotes many negatives to our children. I would agree with you that to stay home and not celebrate at all is a cop-out, but I disagree that choosing to celebrate in a different manner is. Actually, the different way is what you will be doing, in my opinion – because that form is what has moved away from original intent. I do not judge you for your choice, but I do think it would be wise for you to check what is leading your motivations. Is it really so you can meet your neighbors, or is it something else which leans toward being a man-pleaser?

Lovingly submitted,
Carolyn L.

John Fischer Responds
There are times to be counter-cultural, I just don't think Halloween is one of them. Mainly because our reasons for non-participation are lost on our non-Christian neighbors who do not see Halloween as anything other than dress up fun for the kids.

Bonnie Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Powers, MI, USA
Fear or Discernment?

Dear John,

I appreciate much of what you write and often forward your messages on to friends. Thank you.

Our family doesn't celebrate Holloween - we don't attend alternative "dress ups" at church either...we just do what feels right for us.

I think we need to be careful when it comes to telling each other what we - as believers in Christ - "should do" when it comes to this or any other day of the year. Our own decision to not celebrate Halloween isn't out of fear - but rather discernment. I'll try to explain:

1.) We try to teach our children healthy eating habbits - so it doesn't make sense to us to take them out on this day to fill (whatever is used) to gather sugar-laden "junk". Our bodies don't function as well on that stuff.

2.) People tell their kids, don't accept candy (or whatever) from strangers and don't beg...yet on this day we should take them out to beg for candy from strangers?

3.) The immages we see throughout the stores etc. are horrifying. As my daughter said yesterday, "I can't wait till Halloween is over, then I don't have to keep seeing all those bloody, ugly masks etc. everywhere." We'd rather focus on things that are lovely etc. (Philippians 4:8)

4.) Speaking of immages - what about all those scary movies. Why would we want to plant images of bloody murderous rampages in our minds...or our the minds of our kids? As a teenager (25 years ago)I watched one such movie. Amongst all the bloody scenes, there was a scene where a long knife was strapped to a teenagers trumpet. The killer had tied the teenager to a tree and used the trumpet as a murder weapon - each time he blew into the trumpet and extended the bar, the knife was thrust into the back of the teenager. Still today, everytime I see a trumpet, that scene comes to mind. I can't help it, I wish it didn't...but it does. When our son was in band - the instructor said "he'd be good at the trumpet"...I cringed because this scene came to mind. I hate these scenes...and so rather choose to avoid the scary movies.

5.) We are a financially poor family - I'm not complaining, as it allows for a greater appreciation for what we have. If I had ten dollars in my wallet right now, I'd use it to purchase food for my family or something useful. The thought of spending my hubbies hard earned money on sugar-laden candy instead of meeting real needs just isn't fitting for us.

I feel as brothers and sisters in the Lord, it is important for us to not paint one another as fearful or narrow minded when it comes to the traditions of man. Each should choose for themselves what feels right and not judge another (whether they celebrate or not)...that would be the real loss to Satan. This is not to say you are judging anyone - and neither am I...but it happens.

If there are others who have discerned that Halloween is something they'd rather avoid for themselves and their children, may I suggest a couple of things we did as our children were growing up (not telling you what to do, but sharing healthier alternatives that worked well for us).

We skipped school on that day and each year did something fun and different:
1.) Went bowling
2.) Went swimming and played raquetball at YMCA
3.) Went to park, had a picnic and played on the equipment

We did other fun things as well, and over time, we had other kids that were asking to come with us, eventually we needed two vehicles to take all the kids that wanted to go. It was great times of laughter and play...and fellowship.

John, I hope you and Chandler have a great Halloween as you celebrate according to your own convictions.

Your sister in Christ,
Bonnie

John Fischer Responds
Thanks. We will!

EJ Watson Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio
I have been struggling a little with Halloween as I have gotten older; it seems so much darker then when was I was a kid (I am 45). But, that being said, I took my kids trick or treating on Saturday...our neighborhood always does it the Saturday prior to Halloween...my wife stayed home and dispenced candy. Our children are 6 and 7…it was the first time they had gone…the circus is always in Cleveland the last two weeks of October (how convenient). They went as Edmund and Lucy Pevencie (my kids spend a lot time in the happy land of Narnia). I was a little surprised that only one person asked who they were supposed to be and then had no idea about the Pevencie children or Narnia...I guess I don't get out much. At any rate, we had a good time together and after reading your thoughts this morning we will probably "celebrate Halloween" again next year. Thanks.


Camille Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Leesburg, FL, US
Hear, hear, John! I was briefly been in a church like that in the 70's - no Halloween, no Christmas or Easter (pagan origins), no birthdays, no patriotic holidays (nationalism was bad) etc.. It set my family apart from neighbors, friends and extended family and created misunderstanding and division. I am so glad to be freed from that kind of legalism and appreciate your efforts to set others free from it too.

Pam Edson Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Hallelujah, and thank you! Halloween has been an especially exciting day for us for the past nineteen years now. It is our son's birthday...and yes, he was a bit of a trick (a little early) but mostly a treat. He's had to grow up sometimes defending himself for having a birthday on such a holiday (which we always celebrated in the way that you have described). The other thing that goes unnoticed often on this day, except for us Lutherans, is that this is Reformation Day. So, again, thank you for allowing the celebration!

John Fischer Responds
Ah yes. This is the day Luther nailed his 95 theses on the Wittenburg door. Now that's something worth celebrating!

Deb Collins Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Fraser, MI, USA
Thank you,

We have a Christian talk show host here in Michigan who goes on and on about how bad Halloween is and I have such fond memories of running around with my cousins getting candy. Now my kids do the same thing with their cousin. About 5 years ago was the first I heard of anyone having a problem with Halloween. I just don't see it.

Thanks!

Danielle Collins Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Lebanon, Ohio, USA
Thanks John,

You have really made my day with today's "Catch".

I struggled this year when my 10 year old son wanted to go as something other than a super hero or a cowboy. I gave in to a skeleton mask, gloves and a cape. I'm not sure I know exactly who he is, but he has a name for it.

Thanks for your comments on Halloween. Our family will be doing our part to celebrate life. We will fellowship with our neighbors and friends with a big pot of chili and hotdogs to share. We are going to have a house full.

Baskets of Blessing to you and yours.

Sincerely,
Danielle Collins
Lebanon, Ohio

Fred Michaelsen Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Andover, MA, USA
I think you're likely to catch a lot of flak on this commentary, John. I, for one, disagree with you. I wasn't a church-goer when my kids went trick or treating so now I can see the dark side of this holiday. Trick or treat is not exactly a Christian motto, it's worldly by nature. And where does a trick end and vandalism begin? At that age, we're teaching something that's hard to eradicate at a later age. While you're correct that it was originally a Christian holiday, today that is totally lost. Today it celebrates the dark side. I often dressed as Satan and he became a "beloved" character. How are you going to explain to Chandler in later years that Satan really isn't beloved? Witches and ghosts? And would Jesus think it worthy of God to jump out of the bushes and scare little kids? (I use to get on the roof over the front door with a sheet over me. As the kids came up the walk I would light a flashlight under the sheet and howl like a ghost. Scared the heck out of the kids. Or did it traumatize a few?)
I sense a lot of rationalizing in justifying the celebration of Halloween. It gives me permission to justify doing other things that are not worthy of God so as to mingle with my friends and neighbors. So I think you're wrong and I'm disappointed that you think otherwise. I'm disappointed also that you think those who object to celebrating Halloween are over-reacting. All the "good" things you mentioned can be more effectively accomplished by YOUR organizing a block party at times during the year; by showing the gift of hospitality and inviting neighbors to dinner.

John Fischer Responds
The block party is a great idea. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

Valerie Snapp Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Amen! Thank you for putting into words my feelings on Halloween. Anytime I get a chance to "playlike" or play dress up with my grandchildren (yep, did it with my children, too!) I'm having a blessed time!! And, the candy is an added "treat"!
Thanks, John!!

Eric Chapman Tuesday, October 30, 2007
Roswell, NM, USA
This will be the first year we are not allowing our children to participate in Halloween and we will not be handing out candy. I feel as Christians we are sending a mixed message to our children if we allow them to participate in a pagan holiday. I refer to the following passages:

"Test everything. Hold on to the good. Avoid every kind of evil. [1 Thesalonians 5:21-22)

"... have no fellowship with the unfruitful works of darkness, but rather reprove them." [Ephesians 5:11)

"For what do righteousness and wickedness have in common? Or what fellowship can light have with darkness? What harmony is there between Christ and Belial?" [2 Corinthians 6:14, 15]





John Fischer Responds
Thanks for expressing your thoughts on this. I would only suggest that participation in Halloween need not be in violation of these verses if one is finding out what is good in a cultural tradition and holding to that.

Go Back


Copyright © 1997 John Fischer
All rights reserved

If you encounter difficulties with this web site, please notify our webmaster at Onto Technology, Inc.

348819