In The Tank Comments

Reference Text
The Improbable Truth Monday, July, 12, 2010
by John Fischer

Has it ever made anyone curious why the Bible questions its own answers? Take the book of Ecclesiastes, for instance—twelve chapters dedicated to the propagation of the meaninglessness of life. And this is not just the author having a bad hair day. This is an investment of a wise king's entire life seeking the meaning of his existence. Every attempt to answer the big question is meticulously pursued, and with all the resources to make it legitimate. If Solomon wanted to pursue wealth, he had wealth to exceed the richest kings at the time. If he wanted to pursue pleasure, he had a thousand concubines at his bidding. And in his pursuit of wisdom, his wisdom was unparalleled in human history.

King Solomon was no armchair philosopher. He had the opportunity to try out each one of his solutions, and every time he came up with the same conclusion: "Meaningless, meaningless… Everything is meaningless" (Ecclesiastes 1:2). And even when he does concede, in the end, that the only reasonable thing to do is to fear God and keep His commandments, it's not like he's ready to celebrate this final discovery (Ecclesiastes 12:13). In fact, it reads like a resignation. You finish this book and you want to go, "When's the next Tony Robbins seminar? I need some cheering up!"

Actually, the fact that Ecclesiastes is in the Bible does two things for me. First, it gives me confidence that the rest of the Bible is true. If Christianity were a construct of the human mind, you wouldn't find this stuff in its portfolio, that's for sure. What propaganda features differing views? Who includes the opposing arguments in their literature, and even makes them look good? And yet the Bible declares life meaningless, it shows bad people having a good time and good people having a miserable time. The hero of the whole book dies a brutal death in the end, for heaven's sake, and then He calls His followers to come and die with Him! Well, whoopee! Where do I sign up? I'm sorry, but to all those who say someone made up Christianity, I have to say, based on what? Certainly nothing I know of in human nature.

Secondly, it makes me look more deeply into things. Maybe the reason following Christ doesn't magically make this life a party is because there is something more than this life to consider. And maybe Solomon was so old and spent by the time he finally got to it that he couldn't really enjoy what was enjoyable about what he found. And maybe, just maybe, the reason God put his story there was for us to benefit from his life's search, take his word for it, and start living where he left off.

Comments Go Back
Today's date: Friday, September 10, 2010
Beverly Tuesday, July 13, 2010
Wilton, CA, USA
I did, I really did get the point, but I also got my laugh of the day. You said if Solomon wanted to pursue pleasure, he had a thousand concubines at his bidding. If you had been saying what would bring a woman pleasure, You would have said that she had spas, hairdressers, huge wardrobe, etc. at her disposal. See why I had to laugh?


John Fischer Responds
I get it!

mark Clark Monday, July 12, 2010
Lake Wales , FL, USA
John,
Thanks for the insights. I like a thought I once heard about Ecclesiastes, "Everyone has a purpose in life...even if it is to serve as a bad example." I also happened across a little commentary written by an airline pilot (hopefully during crew rest and not during cockpit time!). He proposed that Ecclesiastes is a study in midlife crisis. It is the work of someone in the throes of self examination and frustration with what they see and what they know.

Ecclesiastes has always been one of my favorite books because of the honesty and transparency. God is secure enough in His relationship with us to show us the joys and the sorrows of that relationship. Even in the depths of contemplation and confusion, Ecclesiastes points us to the best hope for our own frustrations.

Let the laughter roll! Psalm 126:2-3

Mark Clark

Joanne Monday, July 12, 2010
BRAVO!

Drew Snider, Gospel Mission Monday, July 12, 2010
Vancouver, bc, Canada
Utterly brilliant! But it begs the question, why DO I feel happier and more joyful now than I ever did when I was "in the world"? Why, when I came to the realization of the Truth, did I not feel oppressed and crushed by the knowledge that life as I knew it was meaningless, but rather felt absolutely unstoppable?

John Fischer Responds
Because you know you are right. The truth has set you free.

Greg Monday, July 12, 2010
I liked this catch. One thing I have been considering lately that I think goes along with what you are saying (though you may not agree with my point, I'm not sure I even agree)is that perhaps the Bible a collection of writings by various people each giving an angle on their experience with God. Inspired by God, but each as a seperate volume. To me that might make more sense than looking at it as a book used to build systematic theologies from. If it were meant to be used that way (as most of us conservatives have used it in recent times) it seems like God would have just given us 25 points of theology and made it simple and avoided a lot of argument. Maybe HE intended to leave it a bit more open-ended than we sometimes let HIM.

John Fischer Responds
Couldn't agree with you more.

Go Back


Copyright © 1997 John Fischer
All rights reserved

If you encounter difficulties with this web site, please notify our webmaster at Onto Technology, Inc.

358167